The fourth and final season of Yellowjackets, the Bataillean soap opera that is also a teen coming-of-age relationship drama about primitive state formation, premieres tomorrow. Yellowjackets is a program that has, without exaggeration, changed my life since I discovered it three and a half years ago, and I am determined to read it reparatively come hell or high water, despite qualms about the third season and further qualms about what’s known of the intended direction for the fourth. Because of the economics of modern television production, to say nothing of what I have described as “the infamously entitled reading style of modern media fandoms”[1] (not exactly unrelated issues), it is difficult for a show like this to stick the landing, and in this case that problem has been exacerbated by political and cultural shifts since the show started in 2021. These are well-known to anyone following entertainment news. “Paramount Skydance” is at issue.
I suspect I will end up advancing some kind of model of a bifurcated Yellowjackets canon. “Canon” is a word that I am here using to mean that which has to be taken at face value in order to arrive at an honest understanding of what story is being told. It would be easy enough to just decide that anything about the show that I don’t end up liking in the final analysis isn’t canonical. That, however, would be the entitled reading style rearing its head again. There must be some external criterion that can be used to inaugurate a reasoning process about what this story, as opposed to another story, “would” or “should” be or have been like, even if the process is still inevitably one of motivated rather than dispassionate reasoning. Fortunately, in this case there is a permission structure for identifying such a criterion that is already being offered by the series’ creators and stars. I do not, in general, believe that the final authority on the meaning of a text is the reader rather than the author, but co-creator Bart Nickerson does,[2] and so the fact that he believes that becomes itself part of the series’ meaning. Star Sophie Nélisse and others have said that filming parts of the final season did in fact feel like filming material for a different, related show, one that didn’t have Yellowjackets’s “heart.”[3] So there is probably going to be some of the last season that can be bracketed off without driving a coach and horses through a reasonable construction of what Yellowjackets “means.” One might even be able to do it with anything after the second season. After all, the period between seasons two and three involved multiple entertainment-industry strikes; obviously worsened relations between the show’s writers and the network and distribution company suits; Donald Trump’s return to office; the “Skydance” issue coming up; and people like Karyn Kusama, one of the original executive producers and director of two key episodes, leaving the show.
Eco’s distinction between a fabula and a discourse might also come into play here, as it already has with my personal assessment of the merits of season three.[4] I have come up through Tolkien fandom, in which making this distinction is impossible to avoid even if for some reason one wanted not to make it, because of formal features of Tolkien’s body of work. Yellowjackets lacks those specific formal features, but I think that a critique of the circumstances of its production can yield similar conclusions, as with “weird TV” of yore like The Prisoner and the original run of Twin Peaks. (Perhaps the ending of Puccini’s, or “Puccini’s,” Turandot might provide a more direct basis for comparison; the direct analogue to that in Tolkien would be the chapter of The Silmarillion in which Thingol dies, rather than the broader issues around Tolkien’s tendency to constantly revisit and retcon his ideas.)
What, then, do I believe Yellowjackets “means”? Some people think that the first season and the first season only is a core thesis statement and directive principle of what the series ought to be. I don’t agree with this. The Yellowjackets with which I fell head-over-heels in love is the world of the second season, especially in the teen timeline, i.e. the “primitive state formation” timeline. This is the world of vanishing and reappearing moose gods, all-hands-on-deck spiritual and epistemological arguments between a bunch of teenage girls who have no idea what they are talking about, and constant bizarre serendipities connecting the show to Saint Kateri Tekakwitha, of whom I was becoming a fervent votary around the same time I started watching. This is the Yellowjackets in which “free speech applies to the seraphim in one’s head as well, and the breakdown of the bicameral mind is a civil liberties violation,”[5] which “tells the story of a turf war between a Francophone demon and an albino moose for the souls of a team of lesbian soccer players.”[6] I am unlikely to see its like again, because of the agonizing perfection, in terms of my own desires for stories, that it obtained—and, crucially, obtained only in fits and starts, in occasional grasping glimpses. This was never one of those formally perfect shows that enter and exit one’s mind leaving no traces because there is no friction in them.
In fact there is significant rockiness even in “my” Yellowjackets seasons, which is why I think that attempting to slice and dice the show according to what parts of it one merely thinks are “good” or not would just be yet another example of the entitled reading style. Season three, for example, lacks any groundedness in the ecological reality of the Canadian North Woods. There should be black flies in almost every scene.[7] Characters should be unable to get through a sentence without having to pause and swat one. Whenever they’re not there, Van or Mari or someone should be asking, “where are the black flies?” Exposed skin should be seriously problematic; the real reason none of the Wilderness-bound Yellowjackets seem to lastingly give up wearing bras is that they want to keep the final line of defense against becoming lords of the flies in an even more uncomfortable sense than their Golding-penned forebears. But already in season two the fake snow looked tacky as hell. The internal chronology never made much sense, and season one has some iffy acting from actresses who blossomed later on.
The meaning that supports and sustains all this, especially in the first two seasons but in the best parts of season three and I expect and hope of season four as well, has to do with, for me, three distinct preoccupations. The first we might identify as compulsory heterosexuality and its discontents; the second, as Jamesian empiricism; the third, as a wide-ranging but probably-accidental critique of the Christian mystical topos of the wilderness or desert.[8] What the program “should” be is faithful to this nucleus of concerns. This will determine how forcefully I apply the criterion by which one might argue the deuterocanonical status of, say, the episode that wastes several minutes on Jeff doing stand-up in a nursing home (itself ripped off from, and/or a cryptic reference to, Better Call Saul) before Lottie dies at the end.
Then again, of course, it could all be totally fine and provide no cause for vigorous critique or soul-searching from my point of view at all. All will become clear soon enough. As they say in the Wilderness, we won’t be hungry much longer.
❦
[1] N.M. Turowsky, “Must Art Be Good?”, in Turowsky, Poachers in the King’s Domain and Other Sacred and Profane Non-fiction (Greenfield, Massachusetts: Cymbidium Books, 2025), p. 220.
[2] I think I just found the source for this that I saw the other day, but I don’t want to watch “pivot to video” content right now so I’m not sure. I’ll cite it anyway. Katie Doll, “Yellowjackets: Will the Supernatural Mystery Be Solved?”, Comic Book Resources, November 16, 2026, https://www.cbr.com/video/yellowjackets-will-the-supernatural-mystery-be-solved/.
[3] It’s even harder to find a non-agonizing source for this one, especially if you have limited tolerance for people attempting to derail Nélisse into talking about Heated Rivalry instead of Yellowjackets (O tempora! O mores!). She has brought it up several times on the season four press junket and red carpet.
[4] As expounded in Umberto Eco, “A Portrait of the Elder as a Young Pliny,” in Eco, The Limits of Interpretation (Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press, 1990), p. 124.
[5] Katherine G. Benjamin, personal conversation with author, October 5, 2026.
[6] Turowsky, writing as Celeste Saba, “Moose, Explained,” in Save Our Souls! A Yellowjackets Zine, January 25, 2025, p. 26.
[7] Wade Hemsworth sings of this.
[8] Turowsky 2025b, pp. 27-28 et seq.